(27 votes, average: 3.81 out of 5) 
Loading ...
Saregamapa Singing Superstar 19th November, An episode full of shocks. First Ranjeet Rajwada fainted on the set, He wasn’t feeling well for last couple of weeks and fell straight down from his seat, He showed courage and came back to perform on stage after a medical checkup. Sniti Mishrra who has been continuously appraised by the judges as one of the best contestants in saregamapa singing superstar has been voted out today by the viewers. Enjoy the videos and don’t forget to watch Bappi Lehri Special tomorrow.
Saregamapa Singing Superstar Highlights
Kamal Khan sings Piya Re Piya Re
Abhilasha Chellum sings Akhiyon Ko Rehney De
Ali Sher sings Aisa Koi Zindagi Se
Bishakh Jyoti sings Bheegi Bheegi Si Hein Raatein
Sniti Mishra sings Suniyo Ji Arz Mharii
Suganddha Mishrra sings Dil Cheez Kya Hai
Ranjeet Rajwada sings Ab Kahan Hoon
Saregamapa Singing Superstar 19th November Videos part1
Saregamapa Singing Superstar 19th November Videos part2
Saregamapa Singing Superstar 19th November Videos part3
Saregamapa Singing Superstar 19th November Videos part4
Loading ...
Felt very bad to see Sniti go. I feel very sorry for all her fans (including me).
I am sorry Aruna/Samar/Juliet, as your favorite singer had to go this early.
Actually, I realized one thing, that all the contestants in last 7 were equally talented. They had their own unique strengths, where everybody else lacked. They all should be winners. It will become more and more difficult to choose one, and see others go. Now, it’s touch and go. One bad performance (not necessarily bad ‘technically’) in public’s view, or one wrong song selection, and best one can go. I was so surprised to see Bishakh unsafe. How can one explain that?
Afzal, dude, I’m first this time!!
I felt really bad to see Sniti out of the contest. From episode 1 of saregamapa, Sniti had lifted saregamapa to a different level with her strength in classicals and sufiana.
I wish Sniti all the very best in her career as a singer and attain the heights as that of the legends Lata and Aasha ji.. Because her unique voice and quality of singing are her strengths one can easily recognize her voice without thinking who might have sung.. While this is not true for rest of the singers.
I thank this website for posting very good quality vedios.. I am proud to download all of Sniti’s performences (ofcourse last one is yet be uploaded).
I belief Sniti will come back into our lives soon with very good albums..
As a Sniti supporter, I would wish her to maintain a balance in stage performance and albums.. Because both are important as a singer of her zoner and quality. I wish her all the very best!!
I think Sniti was the right choice and order – to have to leave the show. I am sorry for your loss(All Sniti fan.) . Having a unique voice does not necessarily mean a pleasing voice. It was visible she was classically trained but neither her diction nor her sur were ever up to par with the others. And if you listen to the judges comments on most of her performances they always said- her surs were always off . IMHO she was always overrated and took away limelight from those that truly deserved praise. Having said all that, I have to say she always behaved with grace on the stage. and I wish her well. I am sure Shekhar babu will cut an album for her. Talking about Shekhar did you guys see how he made a point to tell Ali Sher not to say some words through his nose, huh! Okay this is coming from the guy who did cartwheels hearing Sniti sing through her nose all the time. Today’s show was just eh. Poor Ranjeet. Hope he feels better. Glad to see Abhilasha get praised and Ali sher get highest votes. He truly deserved it.
I think, Sniti was the real winner in this show. i don’t think the rest of the contestent would be the real winner. they r only the viewer supporter not the real singer. They r not singing well. whatever the Mentos commented to Sniti in that last episode was not good, that was really hurted all of the sniti’s fans. they hadn’t comment like this & one thing i like to say again that, Sniti was the only real winner. No one can be like her. i think, i have to leave to watch SaReGaMaPa from today.
I agree with you. We have some very stupid mentors who dont know what the hell they are barking. Sniti you the winner for me.
I am sooooo gonna miss Sniti; she was the unique talent SAReGaMa had… Such a losss…… wish and hope Kamal wins now … else this show will be another disappointment like most of the reality shows where truely desrving contestents finally do not win !!!!
Sniti was the best of the lot. She had all the qualities to be the winner.She sang classical, semi-classical, sufiana, soft romantic songs, dance numbers(of course dance numbers did not suit her voice) with ease and excellence.. She has given the most number of memorable performances than any other candidate. Starting from mora saiyaan jo hai pardesh, jhoote naina bole, mora saiyaan mose bolena, in ankhon ke masti ke, mitwa, yeh honsla, chandni ratein, nigahen milane ko, tere bina jindagi se koi, laaga chunri mein daag, suniton ji, sajan tere bina, etc. all are classics and she is different from all other singers in the history of Sa re ga ma pa. Not only her voice but her unique style of singing and capability has endeared her to thousands around the world. She is one original singer. She may have been out because of script requirement of reality show (but bias in this case is too disgusting), but people have recognized her world over. I expect a an album sooner than later to quench our thirst for her songs. Whoever may be the ultimate winner in this show, SRGMPSS 2010 will be remembered for Sniti Mishra.
If it helps Sniti fans, please don’t worry guys, don’t be so sad!! Look at it this way, she would have gone next week or the week after at the latest. Actually, she could have gone last week, when they temporarily eliminated elimination. So, she might have, in fact, gained one more week, who knows!!
I hope that now all those people who had soooo much to complain about Sniti’s performances are happy. But as I had already said Sniti is already the winner, she was the soul of SRGMP, when the soul leaves nothing relevant is left over.
This is for me the last SRGMP to watch.
Extreme obsession is the best word for Aruna. She lives in world of dreams. Real world is bitter. I predicated Kamal as the winner 2 months before but Aruna was stubborn that time too and was taking it personnel. She thinks she loves Sniti the most. I like Sniti’s voice too and love her attitude and talent and will certainly miss her a lot. But she will come up sooner or later in any other reality show. By then she will be unbeatable. We can’t suppress the talent, long live Sniti. Sniti will rule one day and his day will surely come.
Aruna i am not adding insult to injury as you would think. I feel sorry if i have hurt anyone. We all are music lovers and we don’t have any race, religion or boundries. God bless all
“I hope that now all those people who had soooo much to complain about Sniti’s performances are happy” …….one of them was me…..it was well overdue. Goodluck and goodbuy Sniti. Expecting Ali to go next
Aruna, looks like, you can’t see the things as they are. The people who didn’t like her singing as much as you did, don’t have anything personal against her. It’s just that they didn’t like her singing as much as you did.
What do you mean by ‘She’s already the winner’? Can you please elaborate? Because, the way I see it, and it is, she is out of the show, and not as a winner!! she got the least number of votes, even less than Ali, who is from Pakistan (which could have been a big factor regardless of how good he sings).
SAREGAMAPA team doesn’t force anybody to watch their show, so your not following the show is completely up to you, but please don’t be too emotional to say things like ‘when soul…over’!! Even Sniti herself was not this emotional, who really lost something very meaningful to her after a lot of struggle and hard work.
And yes, I am satisfied (not ‘happy’) with today’s results. Not because I wanted Sniti to loose, but because the contestants who performed better stayed. Kamal is my favorite, but if he doesn’t perform and gets out, I will still follow the show to the end to watch better performances.
Aruna, even I am not interested anymore in SRGMPSS, because it’s clear that ZeeTV decides who wins and not the public vote, give me a break, Sniti the worse of these 7?!
Sniti is the winner because she lives in the heart of millions and srgmp if you have a problem with our view I don’t care.
Where do i start and what do i write?I fell in love with her singing the moment she hit the first note in the auditions and am still in awe of her singing.Her singing had a special dimension because of her personality.I have not come across a person like her on any reality show till date.A humble attitude , a smiling demeanor always , grace under pressure , a positive attitude , stylish without realizing it, a willingness to learn, dignified in every respect and much much more…..A personality anybody would die to have.I feel honoured and privileged to have watched her on this show.She has left behind a lot of cherished memories, more than her singing for me.She will go far in life and we will definitely be hearing more of her in the future.A talent like theirs along with their personality is a deadly combo and irresistible in an industry filled with minimal talent and massive egos.It breaks my heart to write all this, but remembering the grace when she left the show last night, i feel honoured to write this little bit for her.My conscience will not allow me to support any singer i don’t believe in and write about them .Thank you SNITI for being on this show and giving us a glimpse of your immense personality and singing.I can assure you that every music lover of Indian origin on this planet is going to miss you.
I salute you and you will always be a Star for me.Best oF luck dear and may God bless you.
umas
Wow !!! What a brilliant piece you have written ! I am very impressed !
Are you a literary figure? A writer perhaps?
Or mayhaps you are related to Pritam ? Our Lift-baba?
Pritam lifts tunes from other countries, and you lift comments from other forums :D
I also stumbled upon your masterpiece writing here :
Bhagwan aapko aur zyaada shakti de, taa ki aap aur bhaari wazan ke write-ups lift kar sako !
Good work !
Ranjeet, congrats for being in top6 :)
I was surprised Vishal trained him for Ghazal. He himself pointed out to sing other songs besides ghazals. Now that he got a chance, he should have tried training Ranjeet for other songs and test him…
Sniti was the right choice to go…
Abhilasha is excellent, perfect singer. Kamal was not good. Sugandha can sing any songs but her voice quality and sur are not that sharp as Abhilasha’s. She always sings in mid range. Her Classical is good.
Abhilsha should win this competition, but i wonder zee TV will make mumbai girl win????
look at Sajid-Wajid’s comments, they are biased towards their team number, before the announcement of final result they complained about the elimination of Bishakh. If they will behave like that how will expect from them true comments. I think they don’t want to see other team member as the winer of the contestant. Shame to these guys.
I heartily congratulate Ranjeet Rajwada for his performance in that adverse health condition. I wish him and want yo see him as the winner of this show. I also wish all other contestant.
Rratap- Sorry bro you understood wrong. That’s not what he was referring to. Because Manish the host kept on associating the contestants to their mentors while announcing who is going home. To that Sajid commented- “if your’ going to keep separating the contestants at this junction then just let me go now, because at this point I feel no matter who leaves they are part of my team.” I hope this help towards your unfounded accusations towards them. And your comment about sajid-wajid being biased , couldn’t be farther than the truth. For last nights performances they trained all of VIshal/shekhar’s group and look at the results. From Ali to Kamal and Sugandha got nothing but wah wah. Sugandha had not gotten this much praise in any of her performances. Compare that to Vishal – who had always complained about Ranjeet singing gazals only, and when he got the opportunity to advise him – what does he do- makes him sing a gazal. huh! .
Mr Umas, I couldn’t have said it all more beautiful than you about SNITI.
SNITI thank you alot for giving us all these beautiful moments. Best of luck, lots of happiness and succes in further life. Waiting for your album to be released.
Goodbye SRGMPSS 2010
In my perception, the spell binding singing of Sniti in all events greately expanded the spectrum of viewers of “saregamapa” and also created enormous scope for the relatively less-known mentors, except of course “Daler Mehendi” to become known among the increasing audience of “saregamapa”. Last but not the least : “saregamapa” should publicly admit the increase in its revenue generation that “Sniti’s” performences caused.
Shubhankar – Aww! sorry for your loss. I really mean it and I am not kidding. With all due respect, have you heard of the phrase ‘one man’s garbage is another man treasure’. what I am trying to convey is that it’s okay for someone to not love what you love and vice versa. There is only one of you in the whole world, as we are all created unique in our own way. I believe someone’s opinion is only as good as their life’s experiences.. And you proved that by your comments. You have great taste in Begum Akhtar; on the other hand I have my preferences without hating others likes and dislikes. I would especially not go on a rant about someone’s wazood.
Sniti’s singing was truly the soul of this show. She has such an unique voice and had such great
performances, that people will cherish for long after her elimination. And we know these shows
are all scripted. However, she is a clear winner in the hearts of people. Wish her all the best in her
bright future!
Thank you so much Sir for highlighting the true worth of Sniti !
SNITI dear, SRGMP is like a small milestone in your melodious journey. You came, u sang and u conquered..thousands of hearts.You are a beautiful girl with the sweetest smile,i could go on praising ur singing as u r superb,but more than that your persona is admirable,u r graceful,respectful,u carry urself with such dignity and that my dear is what makes u a true gem,because in this industry there are very few that have the qualities u possess.I know the journey ahead will be really challenging but I’m sure, it’ll be a glorious one too. Your true gifted voice and singing speaks volumes about your bright future ahead. We are blessed to hear you sing and I know even your depricators know this in their heart of hearts.Don’t Worry , as one day they’ll recognize your worth for sure.You are a Star and I’m proud of being a fan of yours as you are as great a singer as a human being.
Its been rightly said ‘Success will never be a big step in future, success is a small step taken just now.’ And you have succeeded my dear.
SRGMP 2010 will always be remembered for its rare find – SNITI MISHRA.
Keep Singing and keep SMILING. God bless you for what you are!
Why did you copy my post from India forums? Who gave you the right to do so???
Shubhankar are you okay. really are you OKAY. You do understand we are just talking about a masala filled TRP hog of a reality show. Dude calm down and for goodness sake. Stop… take a breath…. and think …. before you write such vile stuff. For someone who loves music and poetry you are a crude and unkind human. srgmp said nothing to deserve such a vile response from you. Everyone that posts comments here agree to disagree without getting personal and sounding ridiculous.
Hi. Guys I am not here to add insult to injury but I am here to put you guys out of misery. Extreme obsession is the best word for Sniti’s fans. They live in world of dreams. Real world is bitter. I predicated Kamal as the winner 2 months before but they were stubborn that time too and was taking it personnel. They thinks that they love Sniti the most.
I like Sniti’s voice too and love her attitude and talent and will certainly miss her a lot. But she will come up sooner or later in any other reality show. By then she will be unbeatable and very strong. We can’t suppress the talent, long live Sniti. Sniti will rule one day and her day will surely come. The difference in her voice texture will make a difference one day. Just relax and wait. And Guy’s don’t blame judges or Janta. God bless all.
Thanks, Soor. However, the kinds of Sukhbandar don’t bother me much. He has already portrayed himself for what he is in his first post. I don’t see any other post, where somebody agreed with him, not even Sniti fans. Sukhbandar, I am not here to ‘erase those stuffs’ (whatever that means!!), but I think, you are doing it just fine for yourself.
19th Nov Sa Re Gama Pa show was a farce. There was some conspiracy + dishonor to the a great talent like Sniti. 1st, Sajid-Wajid’s comments, they were interested in their stay in the show than a talent being dishonored. 2nd, the there used to three on bottom three. I assumed Ranjeet Rajwada was also in the bottom three and got lowest vote. He was saved from that because of his faint.
Whatever be the case, the voters should not have voted out a talent like. To me, the 19th Nov episode should be investigated about to find out the truth and if there was any manipulation of vote.
Sniti you are one of the greatest singer Orissa has ever produced. My family in Sydney decided not to watch the show. It’s not because we are from Orissa, but it is because we want to revolt against the injustice.
I 100% agree with Umas. Sniti salute to you. We will attempt to see you in person when we visit Orissa next.
Dear Sa Re Ga Ma Pa,
People are watching you. In the race to retain TRPs, I think Sniti has been sacrified at the altar of TRPs, it seems. It is sad that the (so-called) Panch Gurus too have compromised their values on this.
Has anyone watched Ali Sher? Isn’t he mediocre to have been out long ago but for the Pakistani angle?
Sniti did not deserve to be shunted out. Any decision would have been a manipulated one. She is a classical singer and her small town background seems to have gone against her.
Look at the comments made by the Gurus on 19-Nov, and even my 12-year-old son told that Sniti was being shunted out.
I agree with Anil, unbelievable how Sniti was humiliated by the judges, because she had to be kicked out. Even a dog isn’t treated like this.Shame on you ‘judges’!
I also agree with Anil and Simran.It looks like everybody knows or ZEE told to all that we have to eliminate SNITI and comment like she is a very bad singer.It was really very very sad and i just dumb-struck.All the judges tried their best to demean her, belittle her, harass her, torture her to the extent that she would break down. But the one on whose strength they had commented umpteen times stood there like a mountain of courage.SNITI i salutes your courage.After all these comments also u r smiling. I was also surprised with Shekhar’s comments.In each and every episode, he was praising Sniti as a big fan but on the day of her elimination, after such a wonderful performance this kind of comments r nt acceptable.Even if Paa JI also didn’t have courage to praise her.Wajid to pura pagal jese ho geya.Jese ki uska naukri chala gaya.That was also right.All these are bing paid for per episode.So if nobody wii be there in their team then they have to go and no money. After elimination also they even let her speak or sing her last song like khurram.Shame on you ‘judges’ and ZEE.The main problem was SNITI was not fit into the ZEE’s TRP combination.As she is a small town girl.
SNITI Keep singing and smiling ..We all are with you
I also agree with Anil, Simran and Sangeet. Do you remember how the judges praised SNITI after singing ‘Tere bin jiya mora’ and now they are telling her to do some Riyaaz, saying her things to embarrass and humiliate her till an extend unimaginable.
Yes Sangeet you are right, still SNITI stood there as a mountain of courage and as Mr Shubhankar said it very beautifully: bachcho ke baaton par bade roya nahi karte. SNITI just kept smiling.
SHAME ON YOU JUDGES, HOW CHEAP!!!!!!
Shekhar has tweeted that he was very sad about Sniti’s elimination, had a long chat with her and he’s gonna try out a song with her very soon. I think shes a fantastic singer with an unbelievable voice. http://www.twitlonger.com/show/72smuu
From here it is clear that nobody wants SNITI to go.May be they are told to comment like that on that day.I am sure she will come back soon. Her talent has been recognized by many greats.God bless you SNITI.
Sniti you have always been one of the top contestants and what a way to get eliminated! Usually all the judges feel very bad when one of the contestants are voted out, they almost start crying. Strangely enough in your case the judges were the ones throwing you out by giving their unreasonable comments about you, telling how horrible you suddenly sing. You were not allowed to sing a last song, for the first time this has happened!!!!
This clearly shows that the judges are being paid a good amount, when Zee tells them who they want to keep in the show.
SHAME, SHAME, SHAME judges!!!!!!
What is the capacity of the members of the so called “JANATA” to judge a singing? There was also total lack of transperency. They should have come out with the computer generated figures of votes received by each one. Apparently “saregamapa” resorted to manipulation in eliminating Sniti. SHAME ON “SAREGAMAPA” and ZEE TV.
For the episode dated 19th there are already 35 responses and for the event dated 20th there is only one comment. These figures of responses show that after elimination of Sniti, “saregamapa” has become a flop and that viewers do not attach any more importance to it.
Very well noticed Rabi. I didn’t even saw that there are 35 responses for the 19th nov episode and only one for the 20th episode!!
I’m sure that gradually the injustice done to Sniti will become known to everyone and this will damage the reputation of saregamapa shows for always.
Sniti we’ll really miss your performances, I was always looking forward the whole week to your performances and feel very sad that I have to do without this now.
But don’t worry Snitiji, there is a God above there Who sees all, best of luck!
What a SHAME ZEE TV!
Sukhbandar, you are so hilarious!! Even if you stop watching SAREGAMAPA, please don’t stop writing here for upcoming episodes.
REAL1IS1, you put the things in completely correct perspective. Sniti has a unique voice, and a good one, and she/mentors did a mockery here of that voice by selecting the songs, which sounded awful in her voice. When her album comes out with the songs that suit her voice, I would love to get one, but she didn’t belong to this competition.
To all the Snitiji fans. If you were true music lovers then you would have the ability to appreciate good music no matter the source. I am reading a common theme in all of your posts and that is:-.
We are in love with the persona and not the truth. and we don’t care about the other kids who are if not more but equally talented and have worked very hard to achieve this level of perfection..
We loved the judges when they praised her even on days her performances was really shaky and bad compared to others.
The janta was great when they made her the highest vote getter,
Zee was fair and justified in giving her tremendous face time compared to others.
But now we feel cheated -
The judges have become biased and horrible. How dare they criticize her singing.
The janta has no taste and knows nothing about music.
Last but not least . Zee has a conspiracy theory in place.
My point is- the other kids on the show are well deserving of their standings. I have my favorite but honestly I dont’ care who wins. They will all have achieved something that most of us can only dream of. It’s called your DESTINY.
Someone wrote Ali Sher is singing mediocre and has the pakistan angle, to you I say and that’s why you are a Sniti fan. You have no appreciation for talent even when it hits you in the face.
Please stop bashing the judges. Especially Sajid Wajid they have proved to be rather fun, talented and knowledgeable judges on the show. I have already posted what sajid was referring to when he said let us go in response to Manish’s comments.-. He was being nice by saying he considers all the contestants at this junction to be part of his gharana.
srgmp and soor who do YOU think you are to tell the Sniti fans what they should write or not? What great persons are YOU?
What studies in music have YOU done?
Am I telling YOU what to think and what opinion to have?
Looks like YOU two are getting a chance to become judges in SRGMPSS 2011?
I would appreciate if the two of YOU stop spoiling this forum with your nonsense!
simran – are you’re ‘YOU’ in capitals because you are yelling and pointing at srgmp and soor. I suggest you take a deep breath, clear your mind of all biases and let the better person in you surface. Then re-read my post using comprehension skills. Now read your post again. Which of the two posts do you think was hostile, rude and pointless. And what do you mean by spoiling the forum. If by that you mean logic should not prevail in this forum. We should all be a basket case like you. – Judge for yourself – a line from your previous post “Sniti was humiliated by the judges , even a dog isn’t treated like this” .
Simran, you’re right. What we write is nonsense, but just for the likes of you, who doesn’t have any common sense to understand the simplest of analysis and can’t see beyond their own little understanding and biases. I think, you can better understand people like Sukhbanadar, even with his vocabulary of XXXX.
We didn’t just give our opinions, we appreciated others’, too (when those were not biased just for Sniti). Let me ask you some questions, too. Is Sniti related to you? Was it too difficult for you to learn calm, decency from your favorite Sniti?
On another note, did we say, that Sniti will be out, may be even before Ali and Ranjeet? Did that happen? I think, we can understand music at least better than you, as so far, what we have predicted, has come true.
I would appreciate, that even if you stop watching SAREGAMAPA (as Sniti is not there anymore), please don’t stop writing here. May be with Sniti gone now, your posts start making some sense!!
srgmp, start writing Mr Shubhankar’s name properly and now read the message of him: November 20, 2010 at 8:49 pm carefully again. Srgmp, the truth is hard isn’t? Difficult for you to take? Poor srgmp…………………
Hats off to Sniti, she has produces some fanatic fans!! They are so upset with the other people here (who didn’t like Sniti as much), the SAREGAMAPA team, the judges, the whole voting population that voted her out…. WOW!! I think, they should stop mourning, and do something constructive for Sniti. May be a fundraiser, and get her a show overseas, or help her produce her first album.. something constructive!!
I liked the way Sniti left, with the same dignity and decency she had been carrying all along. These fans are actually hurting her that image.
Thanks, Simran, for pointing out my mistake of not spelling Mr. Shubhankar’s name correctly. I sincerely apologize to you him. Somehow, I took it as a variation of Sukhbinder. Sorry!!
Well, back to the point. What truth he was talking about? His post was same as yours, completely biased, and demeaning to others. He made a complete idiot of himself by attacking Soor, and using the words he shouldn’t be, knowing there were respected ladies like you around on this forum. However, that didn’t bother you much, because he was a fan of Sniti!!
Actually, it appears that it’s very hard for you guys to take the truth, which is ‘Sniti is out of the competition and gone for good’. You guys are coming up with unbelievable (and at times, unbelievably funny) things like ‘conspiracy by Zee TV’, ‘humiliation by judges’, ‘worse treatment than a dog would get’, ‘Kamal needs to take many rebirths before coming close to Sniti’ (this one is yours, and my all time favorite!!), etc. So, wake up, Simran, and however difficult (for you) this truth is, take it like Sniti. She didn’t say much, she appreciated whatever she could get from this competition, and left with dignity and a smile. It was a sad smile, but still a smile. She didn’t whine!!
Bishakh does not deserve to be in danger zone. He is one of the best contestants . Sajid’s comment was weird. As a judge, he should know what happens if his contestants gets eliminated.
I was relieved to see Ranjeet standing. I really hope that he gets better
Wow Soor. So well expressed. I really think that Sniti is special, but blindly praising her when she still needs to improve will not help her. We have to be realistic and accept the truth as it is . Kamal is my favourite and will always be. But, I wont be happy if judges do not point out his mistakes as this is not going to help him improve. If someone else does better and wins . I will stiil not worry. May the best win.
Priyam – Thanks… .
I have gone through all the mud-slinging and defensive responses of “soor” and “srgmp”.They are not able to deny facts such as: (1) the spell binding singing of Sniti in all events greately expanded the spectrum of viewers of “saregamapa”, (2) Snii’s singing also created enormous scope for the relatively less-known mentors, except of course “Daler Mehendi” to become known among the increasing audience of “saregamapa”, (3) her spell binding performences contributed to the increase in revenue generation of “saregamapa”, (4) the members of the so called “JANATA” do not have any knowledge & expertise in musicology / music, to judge a singing, (5) there was also total lack of transperency., in as much as “saregamapa” did not come out with the computer generated figures of votes received by each one and (6) the data on the number responses received for the episodes dated 19th and 20th, November, show that after elimination of Sniti, viewers have lost interest in “saregamapa”, thereby rendering it a flop.
“SOOR” in its comment sent at 4.48 am on 22.11.2010 has said, “we loved the judges when they praised her even on days her performances was really shaky and bad compared to others”. Apparently it is a false comment, because “SOOR” is not able to specify the particular episodes when Sniti’s performances were shaky & bad. More over It should be noted that to make a comparision, there should be “level playing field”, i.e. each one has to sing the same song.
It was noticed that in the episode graced by HRITIK ROSHAN, one particular artist had been obnoxiously & very visibly trying to physically attract his attention.
“SAREGAMAPA” as now conducted, appears to be a platform to select a melody-party singer, who can copy the voice & tune of the respective play-back singer and can add attraction to the show through physical actions. It does not appear to be a platform for identifying artists with originality. Snti is an artist with distinct and rare originality, as admitted openly by all, and even by A.R. Rahaman.
Now that the murky affairs by “saregamapa” have been exposed, even at this belated stage it should come out with the statement that it did not like to any more keep an artist with such distinct & rare originality, on a plat form designed to select melody-party singers and it should in all fairness apologise to Sniti for the disrespectful manner of removing her.
rabi – Sorry but I have to ask- Do you even know what mud-slinging and being defensive mean. I have nothing to defend, I don’t care who wins, at this point they are all winners. For your long post, you couldn’t even come up with something original to say. You just cut and pasted your old posts. Well, they did not make sense then and ditto again. It shows you did not even bother to read my post and reflect before going on a rant.. Tell me did you vote for Sniti – if yes then you are part of the janata that you keep referring to in derogatory manner. If you don’t consider yourself janata then you must be from Mars. and If you did not vote for her then too bad that’s why she had to leave. And what’s this nonsense about a contestant trying to physically attract Hrithik’s attention. See we differ here again, I let the good in me make judgements about others. – the good in me thinks all the girls- Sniti, Sugandha and Abhilasha have shown nothing but grace and poise all through the season.
Completely agree with Priyam and Soor. Priyam, obviously my favorite is Kamal, too. I wish he wins, but only on the merit of his performances. I like Bishakh and Abhilasha, too, who can (especially) pose a real challenge for him. Sugandha – I don’t know. Ranjeet is very good, but he still needs to mature, he still sounds quite boyish, yet. Ali and him would be logical choices to go next, unless there is a sympathy wave due to his health! I wish he gets better.
oh! boy….are there any moderators monitoring these posts? how could such comment got through? At least put some automated script filters on words before things gets posted here.
To be obsessive is not unnatural. We become obsessive when something touches our heart. Sniti’s singing ability, her golden voice and demeanor has touched the hearts of millions across the world. Not everybody is able to express the same in blogs.
Sniti brought a breath of fresh air into singing reality shows which otherwise were pushing run of the mill singers. We had heard Raja Hassa, Toshi etc. and Kamal is in same category.We have heard Sumedha, Nihira, Anwesha, etc. and Abhilasha and Sugandha are in same category. There was not singer like Sniti before People are not going ga ga over her voice only, but her singing ability is of the highest order. The way she presents songs of great like Lataji, NFAK, Ashaji, etc. with a freshness ,ease and originality and it appears that the song is being sung for the first time. Mr Subhankar has rightly pointed out her true worth above. It is not hype but reality. Her songs are so appealing that I have heard them over 30-40 times. One can appreciate her songs if one listens her with unbiased mind.
No doubt Kamal and rest are very good singers, but their fans should not grudge the adulation and love that Sniti is getting from her fans.
Rabi, here is my answer to your points:
(1) First of all, how do you say Sniti’s singing was spell binding? Just because there are some obsessed people crying about her elimination on this forum? SAREGAMAPA has been among TOP shows, since it started, and it has had a huge viewership from the begining. Now, growth of internet has added to it, not Snitiji.
(2) All the mentors on SAREGAMAPA are not greats anyway, however, they have been very well known regardless. Have you been keeping up with Bollywood music lately? In fact, they made Sniti (by selecting her in TOP 18, even after her horrible performance ‘Hamen Tum Se Pyar Kitna..’), otherwise she would have been out long back.
(3) Please keep checking (if you have a way to), if Sniti’s elimination has any effect whatsoever on SAREGAMAPA’s viewership. Only difference I can expect is, some of the ‘spell-bound’ fans of her here on this forum will stop watching, which is probably 10 (yes 10, not hundreds, not thousands, just TEN). If just you stop watching SAREGAMAPA, that doesn’t mean the viewership would go down.
(4) One must be a moron to say, that public doesn’t have any understanding of music. The basic beauty of music is, that one doesn’t need to know anything about it to get affected by it, when it’s really magical music. That’s why Folk music is more popular than classical.
(5) Why didn’t you raise such questions, when Mampee went out, or Anshuman didn’t even make it to top 18, or when Khurram got out just after his best performance, or Shreyasi got eliminated? They were definitely more deserving candidates than Sniti. And SAREGAMAPA team is not supposed to show you anything, they must have their own audit in place for more serious reasons than likes of you.
As far as Sniti’s performances go, except ‘Mora Saiyan mose bole na’, ‘Surmayee Ankhiyo se..’, ‘Joothe Naina Bole..’, all her performances were shaky to bad!! In fact, please listen to her ‘Hamen tum se pyar kitna..’ performance again, which was to select TOP 18 out of TOP 52. She shouldn’t have been selected in TOP 18, based on that performance.
Please don’t assume yourself to be an ustaad of music ‘yourself’, and learn to acknowledge and respect people’s choice.
srgmp how do you manage to write so much nonsense? Unbelievable! I really pity you, poor srgmp………………….
srgmp, you don’t even have the courage to use your own name, I proudly can say that I’m Siram Kaur, but it looks like you are either afraid, hiding something. Today you are srgmp, sur and another day gat, vadi, samvadi, teental, jhaptaal?
Poor srgmp………………..
very well said SRGMP. Sniti was a nasal singer. I never enjoyed her singing anyway.
yup. normal person sings from mouth …rest from their nose…LOL! BTW..how is your blood presure now? :D
rabi – Sorry but I have to ask- Do you even know what mud-slinging and being defensive mean. I have nothing to defend, I don’t care who wins, at this point they are all winners. For your long post, you couldn’t even come up with something original to say. You just cut and pasted your old posts. Well, they did not make sense then and ditto again. It shows you did not even bother to read my post and reflect before going on a rant.. Tell me did you vote for Sniti – if yes then you are part of the janata that you keep referring to in derogatory manner. If you don’t consider yourself janata then you must be from Mars. and If you did not vote for her then too bad that’s why she had to leave. And what’s this nonsense about a contestant trying to physically attract Hrithik’s attention. See we differ here again, I let the good in me make judgements about others. – the good in me thinks all the girls- Sniti, Sugandha and Abhilasha have shown nothing but grace and poise all through the season.
Well said, Soor. I was failing to find the root cause of all the rants, cries, derogatory, at times funny, at times plain stupid posts from Sniti fans. You spelled it for exactly what it is. They are very negative persons (or ALL FROM ORISSA), who can only go to either extreme obsession or extreme hate. Look at their posts about Sniti. They talk about her, as if she is either their sister/daughter/or first love. Look at what they write about the people like you or me (or JANTA as a whole), who didn’t like Sniti as much as them.
On the other hand, look at the posts from you or Dev, who obviously like Kamal as much as these guys did Sniti. Still, you never showed any attachment with him, and however ‘spell-binding’ most of his performances have been, you praised or criticized him according to his performance the way you perceived it. Indecently (or not) , JANTA perceived the same way as you did!!
LOL! you’ve hit the nail in *someone’s* head… ;-) it’s quite amusing to see when few loosers goes on personal attacks with abusive language.
This post was for SRGMP…just to clarify…