Forum For Saregamapa Challenge 2009 Discussions

Discussion – 8 Comments

There are 8 responses to "Forum For Saregamapa Challenge 2009 Discussions".

• atmaram says:

  October 4, 2008 at 9:34 pm

  I think that Naina Saxena has given all great perfomances so far and is the best singer so far. I can’t understand why she hasn’t received the hype that she deserves. Debojit is a good singer but his lisp is too noticeable to be a playback singer. Shujat is a good all round singer but he sometimes overuses or misuses classical alaaps and taans in western songs. Zaheer Abbas is the most consistent male performer but he sometimes tries to hard to imitate the original singer’s voice texture.Kaushik is also very consistent and versatile but has a little trouble with high notes. Yashita is a very good singer of western genres but she still hasn’t proven capability for classical and technical singing. Pratibha is a more all round and versatile singer with a nice voice texture. However, in the girls and even overall, I think the best singer is Naina even though she doesn’t get great attention from the public or surprisingly, the judges. Asma is still in the show for appearance and personality reasons which is ridiculous because the show is based on singing quality. Tarun Sagar is okay mainly at punjabi semi classical songs but his voice breaks up horribly at high notes. He was lucky to be voted back in and Asma was even luckier. Shashi Suman should had an amazing mastery of classical control and he should have been voted in. Manisha also was a good prospective singer. It is sad that the indian public is not voting for the talented pakistani singers. I am disappointed in the Indian voting public for not voting based on singing but on physical appearance, personality and nationality.

  Log in to Reply
• nadluvshe says:

  October 5, 2008 at 2:59 am

  Dear Guys,

  I completely agree on the above comment.

  I also agree that the Tarun and Asma dont deserve to be a part of this Saregama as compare to Shashi and Manisha, where i think the first elimination of the show was discusting that Mitika is out. Man she is damm good singer with versatile voice better than yashita

  you are write Yashita doesn’t proves her self in classical and semi classical only western style, i dont think that she will do like pratiba

  Well let us see what is going next in Saregama. Who is going to Eliminated.

  Log in to Reply
• Nirav says:

  October 7, 2008 at 7:45 am

  I think that Naina Saxena has given all great perfomances so far and is the best singer so far. I can’t understand why she hasn’t received the hype that she deserves. Debojit is a good singer but his lisp is too noticeable to be a playback singer. Shujat is a good all round singer but he sometimes overuses or misuses classical alaaps and taans in western songs. Zaheer Abbas is the most consistent male performer but he sometimes tries to hard to imitate the original singer’s voice texture.Kaushik is also very consistent and versatile but has a little trouble with high notes. Yashita is a very good singer of western genres but she still hasn’t proven capability for classical and technical singing. Pratibha is a more all round and versatile singer with a nice voice texture. However, in the girls and even overall, I think the best singer is Naina even though she doesn’t get great attention from the public or surprisingly, the judges. Asma is still in the show for appearance and personality reasons which is ridiculous because the show is based on singing quality. Tarun Sagar is okay mainly at punjabi semi classical songs but his voice breaks up horribly at high notes. He was lucky to be voted back in and Asma was even luckier. Shashi Suman should had an amazing mastery of classical control and he should have been voted in. Manisha also was a good prospective singer. It is sad that the indian public is not voting for the talented pakistani singers. I am disappointed in the Indian voting public for not voting based on singing but on physical appearance, personality and nationality.

  Log in to Reply
• megha says:

  October 11, 2008 at 6:43 am

  it is my sincere request that saregamapa team should keep such rounds where in the participants can prove their talent as all rounders, such as keep semiclassical gazals folk may be vernacular where they can prove themselves and show us that they can sing in all genres, not just western and hiphop and rock which sounds fine and gets the audience tapping but true singing talent should also be done with an acid test. Also the show could do better with lesser of the histrionics, jokes, ego hassles and concentrate more and more on pure singing since the finals are approaching. i am surprised and pained that good singers like prachi mitika and naina got eliminated. does the audience give more importance to asma’s funny hindi mistakes rather than her singing? make her sing please anything classical to gazals and let us decide. Also debojit is a great singer but his diction should be improved. after all this is hunt of a playback singer. But i am happy about one thing that in the case of vaishali the audience did note her flawless singing and not her appearance.

  Log in to Reply
• Chetan says:

  October 12, 2008 at 2:17 am

  I agree that Asma and Tarun should not have been part of this show. I like the comments made by atmaram on each individual but he has left the best singer without comment. I think Vaishali is the best singer and the ease with which she sings will make her top contender for the contest.

  Chetan

  Log in to Reply
• Hina says:

  October 20, 2008 at 7:34 am

  I totally beleive that Asma does not deserve to be in the top 10. SHe is a nice cute girl but because of her fathers immaturity or stupid dicision she is in saregamapa. I hate to think that because of this her mother has left them and by my perspective her father is just exposing her to the limelight and im sure she will loose her innocence soon. I sincerely hope she goes back to Oman and rejoins her broken family. i think we all will rememeber her but i think she is better off there.

  Log in to Reply
• Marziya says:

  November 8, 2008 at 5:18 pm

  I think before saying the word History judges should think 10 times, because now its very tough fight,the episodes still doesn’t feel its serious competition,feel its just a musical show .All are best, but minor mistake, should be also considered (now no excuse) (no sympathy) is last issues. I feel that the word “HISTORY” witticism made as (joke). ITS all public voting, why should we hurt any singer,? Judges thought.

  Log in to Reply
• Zarmina(the real one) says:

  December 12, 2008 at 9:43 am

  definitely i totally agree with Marziya if judges says superhit to any body then next time that person is out like Tarun when Pritam gives him average for one of his performance (o janna) he was eliminated next week, same as Sara when she gets superhit from all the judges she gets eliminated next week straight away. judges should think abt 100 times whether that person is able to get History or not.

  Log in to Reply